Vintage Vibes: Your Guide to Antique and Vintage Shops

At the 1812 Store, you’ll find beautiful pieces sourced from all over the Mid-Atlantic and Northeast, carefully chosen to fit the historic shop’s aesthetic and cater to discerning shoppers visiting to find some of the best antiques in the region. From rustic Americana pieces to Victorian décor, a gem is waiting around every corner.

Aptly named for its close proximity to Letchworth State Park, Trailside Treasures offers a blend of handcrafted and secondhand items, including a wide array of art, clothing, and collectibles. With a location right on Main Street in Mount Morris, it’s a convenient stop as you’re exploring the many other antique shops in the area.

2nd Time Around is a boutique consignment store that offers a little bit of it all — antiques, clothing, furniture, collectibles, you name it. The only thing that remains consistent across all these ever-changing categories of potential items available for purchase? The low prices.

The Not Dot Shop's philosophy is “no one thing does one thing,” and reflects how so many antiques and similar items can be reused, repurposed, recycled, and re-loved, once they find a new home. Will that new home be yours? Head over for décor, furnishings, and homewares.

Simply Positive is the antithesis of a big box store, showcasing local artisans and their products, alongside repurposed goods, furnishings, collectibles, food items, and more. Check the shop’s event schedule before you stop in, you may be able to catch a fun workshop or event, like a barn quilt workshop or paint your partner night!

Find beautifully resorted furniture, as well as china, ceramics, and quilts, at Liberty Hollow South in Mount Morris. Everything you could need to outfit your home with antique, vintage, or retro accents can be found between these walls.

McKay’s Antiques sits within an 1800s building right on Main Street in Caledonia. Named for some of the town’s earliest settlers, the shop reflects the region’s rich history with beautiful antique pieces that hearken back to a simpler time of life in rural America.

On Main Street in Mount Morris, Allegiance Antiques is your classic antique store stocked chock-full of exceptional gifts, furniture, quilts, books, artwork, and more. You could spend hours browsing, the longer you look, the more you’ll find!

Set on what was once a dairy farm, Fox Farm Antiques is now one of the largest antique businesses in New York State. Set aside a good chunk of time for serious treasure hunting - the store covers three floors and over 14,000 square feet.

Head to FLX Revival to hunt for your next great vintage find. The independent, curated vintage clothing shop is conveniently located right next to Sunrise Bouldering and Cosmic Charlie Café, so you can hit up all three local businesses in one swoop. Keep your eyes peeled for vintage SUNY Geneseo and Buffalo Bills merch!

Departing from the many antique shops that offer you a huge range of items to pick through during your shopping excursion, Pete’s Antique Recovery really focuses on a handful of niches: vintage farm and industrial tools, and bicycles. Find collectibles you didn’t even know you needed!

WE Shop is all about women entrepreneurs, empowering them to display and sell their work and providing space for women to hold classes and workshops that are open to the community. Stop in and support Lima’s creative community, and pick up a gift for a loved one or just for yourself.

Furniture, lamps, glassware, china, art, jewelry, and collectibles — you can find all this and more when you browse Reflections from the Past, a well-organized and friendly antique shop in Caledonia. Keep your eyes peeled for rare items dating to the 1800s!

Rather than sourcing antiques and collectibles from multiple vendors, T. Maimone Antiques is a one-owner shop, where you can ask all the questions you like about where certain items were sourced, their conditions, and anything else you might be wondering as you pick through furniture, Americana items, oriental rugs, paintings, prints and more, looking for your next great antique find.

Country Gentleman Antiques is a cozy shop that highlights multiple antique dealers and vendors, for a mix of items and specialties. From décor to furniture, clothing to artwork, there’s a bit of it all.

Carvings & More combines the world of antiques with the realm of all things artisan, with a mix of items from local makers as well as vintage finds. The shop was actually started as an outlet for the owner to sell her son’s chainsaw carvings and now the shop highlights another 30-plus artists, plus a dozen antique dealers.

Are you always the one in your crew to stop at any estate sale that you come across? Then you’ll love a visit to Florence’s Perpetual Estate Sale. The business is named after the owner’s mother, who adored all things vintage and antique and strives to find you something special during each and every visit.

Head to this former-church-turned-antique-mall for a huge assortment of antiques and vintage items, from rarities and collectibles to décor and jewelry. You’ll quickly see why Crossroads Antiques Mall has been in business for nearly 40 years!